George Kiagias

University of Illinois at Chicago Department of Communication

By: George Kiagias

“Initially I had a rough experience with communication advising,” says Gia Donofrio, a senior communication student at the University of Illinois at Chicago. Donofrio is a part of the the communication college, which offers a comprehensive program that has branched out from the typical broadcasting and journalism communication program to a program with more life lessons routed within through the liberal arts and sciences.

“I did not get the best advising from LAS so at first I was a little confused with the whole process,” says Donofrio.

“The problem with the communication department is that there are not many advisors compared to the other colleges at UIC”, says Donofrio. She explained to me that when seeking advising in LAS that it is likely that each time you will be advised by somebody different.

“It is hard to know that you are on track when every time you seek advising the person looking at your transcript is different and is not really sure of where the last adviser left off, says Donofrio. Gia continued to tell me that the number of LAS advisers was greater than the number of communication department advisers yet the availability and opportunity to see either was pretty similar.

“It takes a similar amount of time to be able to see an adviser in the communication department and on the 3rd floor in University Hall. However, I prefer to meet with a communication adviser. The meeting is more personal and they seem to put me more on track with a steady plan from the start to the finish of my education, says Donofrio.

The advisers in the communication department maintain a better relationship with their students, a more personalized one. However, it does not change the fact that there is a major shortage of advisers in the communication department compared to LAS.” It is amazing to see how there are so many advisers in (UH) and to see only handful in the communication department. However, at the same time Christina Zimmerman does a great job and really helps me out with any issue I ever have with my classes,” Donofrio says.

“I would say that the overall process of advising that takes place in the communication department is positive,” says Christina Zimmerman, an adviser in the college of Communication.

Christina went on to tell me that the biggest challenge when scheduling classes in the communication department has to do with prerequisites and the 100 level classes. “Students find that entering communication 101 is difficult until entering their senior year. Early registration gives priority to certain students while others will wait multiple semesters before being able to take the class.”

This as a result may slow down the process of a student finishing on time considering that prerequisites may hold them back from moving on a taking a higher-level course.

“It’s ridiculous to get into communication 101,” states Donofrio.

“It is just a matter of not having enough staff. If we had more staff I do not think there would be as much as an issue with entering these lower level classes and advising on a level that is keeping these communication students on track,” says Zimmerman.

“For the most part I have gotten into the classes that I needed, but the process of doing it was pretty exhausting. I think the communication department needs to hire more staff in order to get the department running a little more smoothly,” says Donofrio.

Interview with Demostenis Fountalas, Student of the college of business

By: George Kiagias

Q: Are you happy with your overall scheduling of classes? Meaning, do you find it easy to pick classes and set a schedule that works well for you?

A: “Absolutely. I have never had a problem finding classes that I need or setting a schedule that works well for me.”

Q: Do you feel like your adviser keeps you on track and gives you relevant information?

A: “Yes, I have looked at my transcript personally and everything that my adviser has told me matches up to what it says in the catalog. I am moving along with my classes without taking any unnecessary steps.”

Q: So you feel that your department is properly staffed?

A: “Yes I have never heard complaints from friends that I have in the business department. They all seem to be pretty satisfied.”

Q: Will you be finishing on time here at UIC?

A: “Yes, I am on track to finish on time.”

Q: so overall you would say that the college of business does a good job with advising and that they have provided a good advising experience for you?

A: “Yes, I honestly have no complaints.”

Analysis of CS Interviews by Alex Alvizo

Earlier in the week, four interviews were posted here concerning the advising process at the Computer Science department at UIC.  The following is an attempt to analyze the students’ comments and perhaps identify a potentially quality that is either missing or could be improved on according to the students interviewed.  

 

Analysis

Although there were only four interviews done, they seem to have some in common: a sense of dissatisfaction with their advising at the Computer Science department at UIC.  Perhaps if I have performed 100 more interviews, I would have found more people that are very satisfied with their advising.  All four of these students met with their assigned advisor.  The way it works in the College of Engineering is that as freshman, there are about 6 to 7 advisors that you can meet with in order to move on in your academic career at UIC.  After that, each student is assigned to a specific advisor.  Specifically, there are about 400 undergraduate CS majors and about 30 faculty members who advice; these numbers indicate about a 13:1 ratio.  Although at first glance, it may seem like a lot, if we think about a classroom size, a 13:1 ratio seems closer to the ideal.  So if we have this wonderful ratio, why did I get negative results?

 

Student one said, “she did a lot of googling, which I could have done…I thought she would have some insight though…”. 

 

Student two said, “…were very little help overall, in fact, I felt kinda rushed since my advisor kept looking at their watch…CS advising is your typical college advising”.

 

Student three said, “well I wasn’t necessarily in total confusion, but I guess I was just expecting something else besides the expected google answer”.

 

Student four said, “it was quick, I got what I needed and left.  I mean, the advisor actually had very little input, but more input wasn’t really necessary.  So yeah, it was helpful”.

 

These quotes seemed to have been the essence of what each student was arguing concerning their experience in the Computer Science advising.  Overall, at best, a couple of students seem to have been really disappointed while the other two did not like it. 

 

After asking one of the Computer Science advisors about their advising process, she answered all of my quantitative date (number of students, etc); however, when asked about her views on the success of their advising and how students may seem to feel, she said, “I can’t give you the student’s perspective on this process.  From the departmental standpoint, we want to have a clear connection with our students and provide the opportunity for students to ask questions, get advice, discuss careers, internships and any other issues they may have with their course schedule and academic career with us in CS at UIC”.  I suppose this was the politically correct answer but still equivocated around my question. 

 

The advising system at the CS department seems efficient and there seems to be a pretty good ratio of students per advisor, so why the negative feedback?  Well, I realize this is an extremely small sample size—only about 1% of the total population in CS but it is qualitative data nonetheless.  After thinking about these consistent responds, seemingly good process, and some of the main arguments the students were saying, I came to the conclusion that perhaps a key factor may be missing from this particular department.  After careful inspection, the human factor seems to be missing.  In some fashion or another, these students to have been party satisfied with the help they received however felt as if they were missing something, which one student referred to as their “insight”. 

 

There might not be anything to fix or look at it as problematic; however, there might be room for a bit of improvement.  If advisors could somehow offer the “insight” that students need, then these students will either not have anything to point out or perhaps point out other minor issues that could potentially better serve the students in the department. 

Transferring In

Since completing the transfer process and starting at UIC in August, I’ve had some success and setbacks since navigating through the process of registration and advising. I’ve been mostly successful with getting everything in place in my schedule without too much frustration. Though it’s always beneficial to see if an adviser can help you get into a class if you have had trouble registering for it online, I think that learning some foresight and checking as early as possible is important too.

I have noticed some varying methods of counseling in my dealing with different advisers. The department adviser, as one might assume, seemed more knowledgeable on when I needed to have certain classes finished by and what ones would be good to take concurrently. They were quick to clear up anything that was confusing me or didn’t make sense and informed me of the schedules I could set up that had the most manageable workloads.

On the other hand, the college adviser(s) I’ve dealt with seem to expect more from you in advance, in that they often presume you already know what you need to register for and they’re just there to make it official in the paperwork. This is understandable to me, because given the vast numbers in LAS, they probably hope that students were savvy enough to navigate the UIC website and find all the details they needed to know before the advising appointment. But a lot of times, students approach the situation like I did, picking up some general info online but retaining an overall attitude of wanting to get the most important stuff out of a face-to-face interaction, without all the loaded language of a website.

Despite the variance in counseling, I still was given a pretty clear view of what I needed to register for this year. Both the college and the department gave me useful information and pointed me in the right direction whenever I had issues. I think there should be a tighter correspondence between Communication and LAS, so they can prevent any further misunderstandings with students, especially ones who are transferring in like myself. Overall, the system operates smoothly for a university of this size.

A Questionnaire for Comm Majors (By Ross Brandstatter)

To see what kind of difficulties and/or successes had by Communication majors, I typed up a short questionnaire and had several helpful students describe to me their experiences.

In your experience, are there difficulties with clear and proper counseling/advising at your university?

S1: “Yes. In my experience, college advisors (LAS) seem to be unqualified and don’t give specific advice to help students pass, but department-specific advisors have been more helpful in my experience.”

S2: “Yeah, I believe so. Registration for certain classes was often times difficult with trying to get into some classes, but I really just felt like my general Liberal Arts and Sciences advisors didn’t really do anything to help me in terms of helping me sign up for classes or find a major. They were nice people and tried to help I guess, but I mostly felt like I was on my own and had to rely on friends and family and myself to get a lot of things done.”

S3: “Yes. Because LAS does not assign each student to a counselor, I often feel like my advising appointments are very impersonal and ineffective. Since I have a different counselor every time, no one thoroughly understands where I am at in my academic career and therefore, can’t give me the help I need.”

Have you had instances of encountering muddled or contradictory information regarding registration? If so, describe such an occurrence.

S1: “Yes. One of my LAS advisors didn’t know what retroactive credit for my French class was, even though I knew from the UIC website that I could get credit. It turns out the website was right and the counselor was ill-informed. The same advisor mistakenly identified the Polish course I was taking as a Political science course. He didn’t know the department abbreviations (POL vs POLS).”

S2: “No, not really.”

S3: “Yes. UIC’s communication department requires you to gain approval before you can register for 200 level or above classes. I was never informed that you should create an appointment with your advisor to lift the hold on class registration months before, which has made registering for Fall 2013 classes a struggle.”

What are the differences, if any, between dealing with a college adviser versus a department adviser?

S1: “College advisors are much more general and they seem to aim to get people in and out as fast as possible. In my experience, the department advisor has been much more helpful in making sure that all courses are done on time and the major is finished. The advisor also provides useful information when building a course plan.”

S2: “Department advisor is way more helpful and knowledgeable, and helped to meet individual needs and ambitions for my education, and really helped steer me in the right directions regarding my major. With my college advisors they didn’t really help with all that much, and I felt like the only reason I was going in to meet with them was because it was required, or it was required to like take a credit/no credit class when I needed to, but other than that I almost didn’t even really feel the need to go in and see anyone. But my communication advisor is one of the most helpful, supportive, knowledgeable people in the world. Or at least one of the best advisors.”

S3: “There’s major differences. LAS advising is so unpersonalized that it often feels useless. However, I always benefit from Communication advising. I have one advisor, Christina Zimmerman, who understands my academic and career goals.”

Do you see your university as adequate or better at getting students registered for the right courses at the right times?

S1: “Adequate.”

S2: “It depends. I had a very positive experience with my department advisor, so I can only speak on that.”

S3: “No. Registering for classes has always been a hassle. I feel like at times, the school makes it more difficult than necessary.”

What, if anything, would you change to make the process of advising and registration flow more smoothly for new undergraduates?

S1: “Make sure the advisors know what they’re dealing with, have a more familiarity with the courses and individual students’ needs.”

S2: “Well most of my problems had to do with issues that advising couldn’t really solve. Like trying to get into the first 3 required communication classes, 101, 102, and 103, were a really big pain because the college consistently didn’t open up enough classes, or didn’t have enough teachers teaching the class, or whatever the problem was. Despite the fact that those are consistently the most in-demand classes in the department and people need those to graduate. I was lucky to have gotten in so early, but I feel like that’s a big problem that not only communication majors deal with, but even non-majors who are interested in taking a communication class, or declaring a major or minor in that field. Especially considering how much the field of communications has been expanding.”

S3: “I definitely think new undergraduates can benefit from being assigned an LAS advisor who they see all 4 years of college.”

Business College Advising Features Story

UIC College of Business Advising

By: Kayla Stueland

“I have had very positive experiences with the business advising,” says Caitlan Smollen, a freshman business student at the University of Illinois at Chicago (UIC). Smollen is one of over 2,250 business students that have access to the college’s successful advising program, which in part contributes to the college’s success when compared to other business schools.

“The process of advising and course selection is organized and it is easy to maneuver your way through the course selection process,” says Smollen.

“All students are recommended to come in for advising,” says Nilkamal Shah, a business advisor at UIC. Although it is not required, business students get the push to see an advisor through the Business Administration (BA) 100 course that all freshmen are required to take.

Shah is currently one of the six business advisors students can access. To make a general advising appointment, students can schedule it online or over the phone. “In general students can get an appointment within 24 hours,” says Shah.

“The only time I had trouble getting an appointment was during the registration periods, when a flood of students can back up the appointments,” says Smollen.

The business advisers try to maintain good relationships with the students and are readily available for help, says Shah. “I have a good relationship with my advisor so I can call him at any time if I have a quick question rather than having to make an appointment,” says Smollen. “This makes the process less stressful around registration time.”

Shah says that the student to advisor ratio is more than enough to give business students the advising time they need to adequately prepare their schedules and plan out their semesters at UIC.

Needless to say, the advisors keep busy. “In general each advisor sees an average of 8 to 10 students a day,” says Shah. “During the busy weeks around registration we general see up 12 students a day.”

During the advising meeting, the advisors help each student plan their next semester classes, as well as lay out a plan of classes that can be taken each semester until graduation, says Shah.

“My advisor and I created a timeline so I have a plan of what classes I will be taking each semester until I graduate senior year,” says Smollen.” I feel prepared for my college career because I have an organized plan of what classes I need to finish for graduation.”

In terms of class availability, usually students are able to get into the classes they want each semester. “If students come to advising and plan their schedules out with an advisor there is almost no chance the classes they want are filled,” says Shah. If students do not go to advising, they might have problems scheduling classes because of course conflicts, says Shah.

Business students have to pay $500 extra for being in the College of Business each semester. “That money reserves certain classes for only business students; only after all the business students register can non-business students register for business courses,” says Shah. This helps prevent the core classes from filling.

Also, for most classes there are multiple sections. The business department has 87 faculty members, which leads to a plethora of courses students can choose to take. Class size depends on the individual class but most of the general courses have 40 to 50 students, while some of the electives have 15 to 20 students, says Shah.

“I have always been able to get into the classes I need and there is a lot of space in all of the main classes,” says Smollen. “I don’t know of anyone that has had trouble getting into the classes they want.”

Interview with Four Computer Science Students

I conducted four interviews with a few students from the College of Engineering, specifically the Computer Science Department.  I tried to say as little as possible yet prompt the interviewee with enough for them to say what they have to say about their experience with advising.  They did not want to share their names so i refer to them as students.  Also, we did have longer conversations; however, they tended to steer towards very particular directions and nothing was said that was not already said.  

 

The following are the four transcripts from the interviews.  

 

Interview with student One

 

Me:  So, you are in the College of Engineering?

 

Student One:  yes.

 

Me: have you gone to advising yet? 

 

Student One:  yeah, at the computer science department .

 

Me:  do you have an assigned advisor or do you just see a general one from the college?

 

Student One:  I have an assigned advisor.

 

Me:  about how many time have you gone to see your advisor?

 

Student One:  three times, two of them were mandatory and the third was to ask about transferring to a different college.

 

Me:  ah.  Ok.  I know you just said two of those meeting were mandatory; however, were you satisfied with the results?  Did you expect the meeting to go the way it did?

 

Student One:  well, I pretty much knew what to expect…so yeah, I guess.

 

Me:  what about your last meeting, the one that wasn’t mandatory?

 

Student One:  well it was more of like I knew what I had to do anyway.  She did a lot of googling, which I could have done…I thought she would have some insight though, which is why I decided to go instead of doing it myself.

 

Me:  So, overall, were you happy with the results?

 

Student One:  well, I think it could have done better but I had no REAL problem with the advising, I got what I needed, which is the important part.

 

Interview with student Two

 

Me:  So, you are a freshman in the Computer Science department?

 

Student Two:  yes.  I am currently taking my first programming class as well.

 

Me:  how do you like it so far?

 

Student Two:  well, it is definitely very intense; I guess you can kinda see it right now since I can’t get my program to run.

 

Me:  aha.  Yes, I see.  What about the advising process?  Have you gone yet to get help on anything so far?

 

Student Two:  *nods head side to side*  Yes, pretty much to learn not to come back for questions I may I may have.  They told me nothing I already knew and were very little help over all.  In fact, I felt kinda rushed since my advisor kept looking at their watch, as if they wanted to leave already.

 

Me:  oh wow.  So I take it your visit was pretty unpleasant?  Did you not reactive a single act of good help?

 

Student Two:  there was one thing that kinda helped me, but overall, no.  I talked to some other friends and told me that CS advising was your “typical” college advising.

 

Me:  what is this “typical college advising”?

 

Student Two:  oh you know, you go for help but you pretty much get none.  Bored advisors wanting to leave.  Answer your questions with more questions.

 

Me:  I see…about how many times have you gone?

 

Student Two:  about two times.

 

Me:  what have you gotten out of this so far?

 

Student:  well, when I was talking with my friends in the departments and after my bad experiences with advising, they told me that if you ever need any help about what classes to take and questions concerning certain classes, talk to some of the seniors or people that have taken the class.  They will be a lot more help than the CS advisors. 

 

Interview with student Three

 

Me:  So you are also a Computer Science major?

 

Student Three:  yep.  First year at the CS department.

 

Me:  have you gone to any advising yet??

 

Student Three:  yeah, a few…maybe like three times.  One meeting was mandatory. 

 

Me:  were you satisfied with the outcome of each of those meetings?

 

Student Three:  well, the mandatory one, I guess.  I didn’t have much questions so it was rather quick.  The other two, I am not sure too sure how I feel about them.  I mean, it wasn’t anything that I couldn’t research myself and I ended up walking out having similar concerns as when I walked in. 

 

Me:  it seems that it was party successful and partly not? 

 

Student Three:  well…I just think that I rather go to other students who have actually taken classes I want or need to take for help. 

 

Me:  it seems like you are indifferent about your advising experience thus far with the CS department.  Have u walked out of the advising office with no clue on what to do next in terms of picking classes or questions concerning what your school plan is?

 

Student Three:  well I wasn’t necessarily in total confusion, but I guess I was just expecting something else besides the expected google answer. 

 

Interview with Student Four

 

Me:  hey, so you are in the college of engineering?

 

Student Four:  yes.  I’m a computer science major.  Even though im taking my first programming class this semester, I have had previous experience. 

 

Me:  have you visited the advising office in the CS department yet?

 

Student Four:  yeah.  Only once though.

 

Me:  how was your experience with it?  Were you satisfied?

 

Student Four:  mmm….yeah.  I guess.  I mean, I knew what I wanted and I pretty much knew what I had to do.  I guess I just needed someone to agree with me. 

 

Me:  ah.  Ok.  Well I guess it’s a lot more helpful when you come in knowing what you need to do.

 

Student Four:  yeah, I already had everything planned out, I just explained my reasoning to my advisor.

 

Me:  well, it seems like your meeting was rather quick.  In conclusion, overall, you would say it was helpful?

 

Student Four:  well, yes.  It was quick, I got what I needed, and left.  I mean, the advisor actually had very little input, but more input wasn’t really necessary.  So yeah, it was helpful.